For years, the
consensus has been that the EPL is the strongest league in Europe. I never
agreed with that notion but before this season there was at least a solid
argument that could be made; the same can no longer be said. It was also widely
accepted that the quality of the Serie A was steadily declining. Again, before
this season there was a formidable case to be made. This 2011-2012 season has
thus far seen a swift change of circumstances both in England and Italy.
At the
beginning of the season I had stated that the quality of the EPL had declined,
I would like to thank all 20 teams in England top flight for proving me right
*tips cap*. The counter argument so far has, and will continue to be, that the
race for the EPL title is more open and has more contenders than it has in a
long time. To be fair, that statement is true; the race is wide open with both
Manchester clubs, Chelsea, Arsenal and Tottenham (sorry Liverpool) all seen as
real title hopefuls (though it will probably be Manchester City). However,
there are reasons for why the race is close, I’ll explain. The main reason why
the title race is close is very simple, the best (Manchester United and
Chelsea) have for different reasons seen a decline in squad quality while
Tottenham and Manchester City have improved over the last 2 seasons (the only
teams in the EPL that can say that). Arsenal is where they always are, close
but not quite there. I digress; the quality at the top is not the real problem,
it’s the mid-table sides. The top 5 will remain formidable opponents in
whatever competition in which they compete, but what about everyone else?
Perennial top 10 finishers over the past decade, ie. Everton, Aston Villa,
Bolton, Blackburn, etc. have all severely been on the decline, with Villa,
Bolton and Blackburn being particularly bad this season. The bottom of the
league is, and always will, be poor; but the problem is that the number of
truly poor sides is rapidly growing. We have reached a point where come
season’s end, anywhere from 7-9 teams could still be mathematically fighting
relegation going into the final few weeks. That’s unacceptable! Blame the
number of foreigners, blame the youth systems, blame the money, blame Sepp
Blatter (secretly everything is his fault), but something needs to be done, and
it needs to happen fast.
At the
opposite end of the spectrum, the Serie A is undertaking a much-appreciated
upswing. For years, let’s say since 2004, the on-field product in Italy has
just not been very good. The match-fixing scandal rocked the Serie A in 2005-06
causing the on-field product to suffer further. We saw hints of it last year,
but this season has really confirmed that the Serie A is back and in my opinion
better than ever, at least from an entertainment standpoint. Catenaccio is dead
and buried, and most people are thankful for that. This new Serie A has ample
attacking football, adventurous formations, quality young talent, and the Inter
Milan monopoly of the last 5 years is over. There are now, just as in England,
5 legitimate title contenders in AC Milan, Lazio, Juventus, Napoli, and
Udinese. It must be said, however, there are 5 contenders for different reason
than in England. In direct contrast with the EPL, 4 of the 5 contenders for the
title (Inter Milan being the exception) have seen steady improvement in recent
years and look to continue doing so. Now Napoli may lose its stars and regress,
Udinese may lose Antonio Di Natale to old age soon and see a slight dip, but
for now they look great. Napoli’s dominance over Manchester City in both group
stage meetings in this year’s Champions League underlines what’s happening in
both leagues; Napoli having well-beaten Manchester City both times.
Juventus are thankfully back among the best in Serie A and
look to only be getting better in a hurry. As in England, the real reason for
the change in fortunes comes from those outside the top 5. Roma, who are
pretenders to the top 5, are under a new foreign influence with Luis Enrique at
the helm (for now) and if his system works, Roma will as soon as next season
push for the title. Inter Milan will rebuild and be back strong for next season
as well. Cagliari, Fiorentina, Palermo, Catania, etc. have gotten better and
solidify a very competitive top 10 in Serie A.
Serie A will
be losing one of its Champions League spots to the Bundesliga starting the 2012-13
season. I’m not going to say its undeserved because over the past 7 or 8 years,
it is well-deserved, just expect the argument from the Italian FA to get that
spot back to be in full swing by next season. The Serie A is on the rise again
and as one of the top 4 leagues in the world, it should have the maximum amount
of Champions League spots. I’m not going to argue that just based on this season that
the EPL should lose one of its Champions League places because to be fair they have
been the most consistent with at least 3 teams in the final 16 over the past 5
years. All I’m saying is that it can no longer be said, at least rationally,
that the EPL is the best league in Europe. I’m also not going to try and argue
that the Serie A is now the best beacause for me its La Liga; despite the
Barcelona/Real Madrid super-dominance, still boasts the most footballing
quality top to bottom. I just want people to open their eyes and stop thinking
that just because the EPL is what you see most on your TV every week that it’s
the best. In the same vein, people need to stop stereotyping the Serie A as
boring, overly tactical and defense because its no longer anywhere close to
that. The scope of European football is changing; I just hope you’re all paying
attention because it will be good.


